Planning bonuses benefit developers, not taxpayers

Local taxpayers should read it and weep.

They have paid about $1 billion for a bungled, much delayed light rail system that I’m glad to see has generated at least $1.2-billion construction activity in downtown Kitchener.

But the same taxpayers are now, through local councils, shelling out excessive development “bonuses” to the same developers who are already making large profits on high-priced condominium units selling vigorously along that LRT route.

At the same time, not a single unit of affordable housing is included in the hundreds of  condo buildings being approved mostly in my downtown ward by councillors and planners.

That reflects a grossly inequitable payback for taxpayers and was the reason I voted at planning committee, Monday, against a project by Momentum developments that wraps around the beautiful heritage Huck Glove building at Victoria and Bramm streets.

And while I congratulate Momentum for saving the Huck building, I think those bonuses are out of whack.

In this case, they will incorporate a zone change that permits an intensified 25-storey building that will have 300 units. They also include an outdoor park area that will be replaced with a partly-indoor “public amenity area” and parking spaces that will be reduced from 411 to 233.

I voted against the project to protest the fact Momentum has or will soon build more than 1,000 high-rise condos on Victoria and at Charles-Gaukel that include no affordable shelter despite the fact Waterloo Region has 3,000 names — about 10,000 adults, children and seniors —on a waiting list for low-cost housing.

After two Kitchener councillors — planning chairman Paul Singh and downtown representative, Sarah Marsh — declared conflicts of interest and didn’t vote on the issue, the remaining councillors and Mayor Berry Vrbanovic approved the development. Singh’s conflict is because his father owns property adjacent to Momentum sites on Victoria while Marsh’s conflict involves purchase of a Momentum condo.’

Buried somewhere under the blanket of bonuses we are shovelling out to developers is a responsibility that those companies make certain affordable housing forms part of their projects. Meanwhile, local politicians should, but are not, doing their utmost to make certain that responsibility is met.

When the issue returns to council on March 19, I hope councillors remember that, no matter what your income, housing is supposed to be a basic human right for all Canadians.





This entry was posted in Greener City, Heritage, Homelessness, Journalism, Light Rail Transit, Low-Cost Housing, Neighbourhoods, Transit, Vibrant Downtown, Ward News. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Planning bonuses benefit developers, not taxpayers

  1. Glen Woolner says:

    AMEN!! Right on Frank!

  2. Catherine Owens says:

    Great article Frank

  3. Margaret Towell says:

    Council needs to amend this as I know a number of people who recently retired or who will be retiring in the next few years who are concerned about this. Many worry that their fixed pension income will mean they will not be able to afford the increasing rents in the region or find decent housing they can afford. Add to this single parents, and the many families living on a low income and this problem will grow as housing becomes more expensive to own or rent. Frank, please continue to advocate on their behalf.

  4. Jennifer Adams says:

    Dear Mr.Etherington, I do not live in your ward but some members of the group I founded, THE DOWNTOWN KITCHENER TAXPAYERS ASSOCTION do live in your ward. The Assocation was founded out of frsutration with the many issues are, or are not being addressed. I’m looking forward to receiving information from you – I’m meeting with Mr. Meier later today: I’m sure he is aware of the issues. While our assocation is a-political, I’m putting my full support behind Peter Meier. Thi

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s